Thursday, June 13, 2024
66.9 F
HomeLetter to the EditorTo the Editor: Village of Mamaroneck Legal Costs

To the Editor: Village of Mamaroneck Legal Costs

Dear Editor:

I am appalled by the Village of Mamaroneck’s irresponsible legal spending, which is tied to bad decisions made by our village officials.

Over the past ten years, the Village has invited costly lawsuits related to several projects, including Ralph’s Ices, Hampshire, Westchester Day School, Mamaroneck Beach and Yacht Club, and Sheldrake Estates. Each time, our Village has lost in court just to prevent reasonable development in our village, while adding over $7 million in legal expenses along the way – all taxpayer money!

This year, the Village’s Ethics Board found Planning Board Member Cynthia Goldstein guilty of ethics violations, and then Goldstein brought a lawsuit against the Ethics Board and Board of Trustees. This action has resulted in nearly a quarter of a million dollars in legal fees! We actually paid her attorney fees to sue us!

And in the past two and a half years, the Village has spent $187,069 on litigation pertaining to AVC Properties, which received approvals to build three houses. For Fiscal 2019, Village legal spending was $537,421, and of this amount, $119,530 pertained to a dispute involving AVC Properties, a neighbor and the Village. For Fiscal 2020, total legal spending for the Village was $630,871, and of this amount, $65,216 pertained to AVC Properties and $100,042 pertained to the Goldstein ethics matter.

Yet, in just the past six months, total legal spending has gone to $428,832, and of this amount, $138,909 was related to the Goldstein ethics matter and $23,283 pertained to AVC Properties.

So here’s a question for our Mayor: why can’t you work with the relevant parties to sit down and listen to one another to come to a solution? If you were to do this, there would be less suing and more doing.

This wasteful spending of our tax dollars has got to stop—particularly now, during the pandemic, and when the Village budget has been cut by approximately $2.5 million. I hope that most of you agree that money wasted on litigation is far better spent on vital services, roads being paved, wellness and reimbursement to taxpayers.

I invite you to learn more about our new taxpayer watchdog group, Mamaroneck Taxpayer Watchdogs, by visiting We are intent on keeping our community informed about taxpayer spending in the Village, which in our opinion, is out of control.


Kevin Duarte Chon
Westchester County, NY

The next Village of Mamaroneck Board of Trustees Meeting is Jan. 11.

theLoop has been the Sound Shore area's online source of news, information and conversation since 2007.


Notify of

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

oldest most voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Jerome G
Jerome G
January 8, 2021 10:21 AM

why in gods name are we paying any legal fees?? this is ridiculous! taxpayers are paying the lawyers to sue ourselves, sickening

stuart r tiekert
stuart r tiekert
January 9, 2021 3:33 PM
Reply to  Jerome G

The letter is wrong. Taxpayers are not paying for anyone to sue the Village. The letter is also wrong in saying that the Village lost in court on Ralph Ices, it did not, it was successful in protect resident’s interest. There are reasons to be concerned about how the Village manages its legal matters but these are not two of them.

Jerome G
Jerome G
January 13, 2021 12:52 PM

You suffer from Cindy Goldstein delusion Mr. Tiekert. Look at the bill below. We paid a lawyer to draft a lawsuit to sue us! Do you know what an Article 78 is?

Last edited 3 years ago by Jerome G
Jerome G
Jerome G
January 13, 2021 1:29 PM
Reply to  Jerome G

Our group also has the copy of the actual bills, and just from this one page you can see that we paid Atty Leventhal to draft an Article 78 lawsuit against us. We paid a lawyer to sue us!

Jerome G
Jerome G
January 13, 2021 1:51 PM


Leventhal-6 (3)_Page_1.jpg

• C O M M U N I T Y • C A L E N D A R •

Would love your thoughts, please comment.x