Sunday, April 14, 2024
47.4 F
HomeArtsFrom the Vault: New Rochelle's Lincoln School and the Supreme Court

From the Vault: New Rochelle’s Lincoln School and the Supreme Court


This piece originally appeared in theLoop in 2014

One of the most heated battles over school desegregation in American history took place in New Rochelle almost 60 years ago in 1961, seven years after the better known Brown v. Board of Education.

It was a time of sit-down strikes. Demonstrations. School boycotts. Not much different than those in Selma or Birmingham.  New Rochelle was once called, “The Little Rock” of New York.

In 1960, the city’s Lincoln School (now the site of Lincoln Park, Lincoln Avenue, just west of Memorial Parkway) was 94% black. City officials insisted that the school simply reflected New Rochelle’s “neighborhood school” policy, but eleven Lincoln school parents disagreed.

Led by Hallie Taylor, the mom of an 8-year-old student, the parents sued New Rochelle in Federal Court, charging that the city had prevented them from enrolling their kids in schools outside the Lincoln School district.

Documents presented in court proved that since 1939, New Rochelle had rigged its school districts to keep black children at the Lincoln School. White students had been allowed to transfer out to other schools in New Rochelle, but many of them had chosen to attend parochial or private schools instead.

The parents insisted that since their school had been segregated for so long, their kids lagged academically behind every other school in the District.

New Rochelle Historic Landmark Review Board
Courtesy: New Rochelle Historic Landmark Review Board

New Rochelle hired experts to disprove the parents’ claims, but the experts sided with the parents, stating that, “New Rochelle has been remiss in its attitudes and derelict in its duties. The situation has caused a feeling of inferiority for Black students that may affect their hearts and minds in a way unlikely to ever be undone.”

“While conducting the oral history project for the commemoration of the 50th anniversary,” ” says New Rochelle historian Barbara Davis, “we had seen that the decision had a profound impact on the lives of so many New Rochelle residents – the most dramatic, of course, being the children attending the school who had to start anew in other schools.”

In 1961, Federal Judge Harold Kaufman ruled for the plaintiffs. However, the school board continued to oppose the judge’s orders to desegregate.  The U.S. Supreme Court in 1962 let the decision stand, ruling that the Lincoln School boundaries had been intentionally drawn to create segregated elementary school districts

Finally, in 1963, the Lincoln School was torn down, and busing began system-wide throughout New Rochelle. Students could attend any school of their choosing, as long as there was availability.

courtesy: communities

“The words on the plaque that was placed on the 25th anniversary memorial of the decision are most appropriate: “A milestone on the search for unity in the midst of our diversity.”  Davis says.

January 24th, 2020 marked the 59th anniversary of Judge Kaufman’s historic decision.

Originally submitted to theLoop by Wendy Koch


Notify of

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

oldest most voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Darryl Stovall
Darryl Stovall
December 5, 2018 2:05 PM

My first day of kindergarten, there were disturbances and stones were thrown. This was September of 1954. These were called disturbances not riots. I can find no reference to these occurrences.

I was a frightened child who clung desperately to my mother and did not understand. Years later I went back to the site to discover that the hill was empty, school building gone.

April Sandmeyer
January 23, 2016 10:15 AM

Arthur L. Pulley played a big part in winning the Lincoln School decision. He passed away at age 99, on January 10th, 2016. Because he did not make it to age 100, as he had hoped, his widow, Bernice, asked that “his centennial year” be celebrated with commemorations throughout 2016. In keeping with that wish, Jan. 24th is one of the dates we chose, being the anniversary of the historic decision.

• C O M M U N I T Y • C A L E N D A R •

Would love your thoughts, please comment.x